Thursday, 28 October 2010

Yes, Prime Minister (Gielgud Theatre)

Part II

Following on from the theme of Politics and the English language, the play "Yes, Prime Minister" is a worthy example of how facetious political language can fool, charm and entertain us. With every reason and with each twist of plot, we should be increasingly worried, repulsed by the questionable morality exhibited beneath public surfaces. Down they tarried, down a slippery slope, increasing the lengths they would go to secure their own interests, exhibiting verbosity and finally using global warming as the ultimate means under which all ulterior motives to secure oil and international relations could be achieved. Oh and I almost forgot, a BBC interviewer mimicking something between the style of Jeremy Paxman and Andrew Marr. Hilarity must ensue then, except footsteps were already creeping on the landing that is our conscience, realisation, then horror soon replaced it. What is politics nowadays? Have we changed? Is there a simple but popularized tick list which politicians learn to adhere to when they address the public? While the back rooms remain as sneaky and questionably moral as ever? There are certain issues that politicians at least know not to argue against when it comes to public consent and if they do speak what they really think they are hounded down by controversy. David Cameron's ring-fencing of NHS spending seemed to be a move to keep popularity, yet if one considers fairness no section should be exempt from a thorough spending review. Boris Johnson's slapdash link between housing benefit scrappage and Kosovan ethnic cleansing in inner city London was an exaggeration intended to scare members of the public, but in reality it was just a thoroughly misleading use of the phrase.

Perhaps I haven't been clear. Each politician can take a certain issue and try to exploit the public's natural reaction. We are used to the way things are and there are certain words that provoke an immediate gut reaction: Higher Education. NHS. Ethnic Cleansing. Human Rights. GM crops. Nuclear Weapons. Each political stance can take one of these popular/unpopular issues and bring the public on side. In practice, the proposed plan behind a popular issue is not always properly thought out, particularly in retrospect. To make sure we can remain sensitive to new ideas for fundamental and most often interminable issues we need to reject gut reactions by word association and give each solution its due consideration, not only of cause and effect, but also if the proposed solution has practical foundations. Then perhaps, politicians won't be chased by this constant fear of appearing to be immoral or inconstant, then rushed into making only seemingly good judgements or even worse, using these popularised viewpoints to hide their own inconsistencies.

Perhaps if the play did have a moral at all, it was to highlight the relationship between government and governed people. Both groups have responsibilities towards each other and as a member of the latter group we should be more careful in what we ask for. The pressure to gain public approval is what leads to these short-term solutions, often found through sly use of language or keywords, when we should constantly debate for what is the real long-term solution. Is there a reason governments can stay popular only for so long? Surely, we can think just a little bit further than when the current government changes hands.


Tuesday, 26 October 2010

Politics and the English Language

Part I

As I sit in my swivel chair next to my darling boyfriend, to a student meal of pasta and other happenstance ingredients, I wonder how many other couples make a romantic night in of the TV debate, "Question Time". My boyfriend likes politics, I like English. He likes English, I'm fascinated by Politics. George Orwell argued the pair were inextricably linked, rather like a married couple. For the state of language is a good indicator of the state of Politics. In his essay "Politics and the English Language" Orwell argues the greatest enemy of the English language, or any language for that matter, was insincerity. To clarify, under a dictatorship for example, any straightforward use of language would immediately reveal a defense of the indefensible. Picture building an army, used to hunt dissidents, kill opposition and any connecting friends or family- this could be phrased "repatriation of the state." To overcome any obvious lack of justification, one can adopt inflated phrases of speech, euphemisms and exhausted idioms. Another picture now, a worried mother asking if her child will have access to university education, if she and her husband will have a good job and pension, answered with the sentence "a sacrifice we must all make". I am personally exhausted from hearing the words: "awful legacy", "crisis", "sacrifice" and "beyond our imagination" in the place of plain-spoken justification to a question that affects everyone. We are not stupid. Lecture us on the faults of your party's opposition, drill us with meaningless phrases and attempt to light the fuel of patriotism- ideas still need foundations, and these are hollow.

Back to Orwell now: if language is continually abused in the name of Politics, then words and phrases become associated only with vaguely positive or negative feelings: Democracy = good, anything else = bad. The irony is for a democracy to work, people need to be able to think clearly, using language as a tool of thought and discussion so one can fulfil one's responsibility to the state- we can't afford to be lazy with language.

Thankfully, we do not live in a totalitarian state, where "Newspeak" (the reduction of words in the dictionary annually from Orwell's "1984") thwarts our ability to form coherent ideas and arguments. Thankfully, the words "Labour's legacy" have been repeated to the point of instantaneous groaning all round. Thankfully, we have open debates such as "Question Time" and hopefully, we can rely on people at home to sort the sincere comments from the ones less so. If you are a member of a party with an opposition, you will have ulterior motives: make the opposition look as shambolic as possible.

Friday, 15 October 2010

"A Room of One's Own" and "Orlando" by Virginia Woolf

Fact does not necessitate truth. It seems so obvious now, like an unspoken and ever-present gospel. A list of facts in a history book would leave much to be desired, but when combined with the imagination of a novelist, a little fiction, somehow it's so much more satisfying. How do we find truth? If we look at how people talk in everyday gossip; in a melange of "she saids" and "he saids"; if we look in a courtroom, there's a prosecutor and defendant. We are the judge sitting under a superior wig, scrutinizing every piece of evidence over a pair of pince-nez. What is common to finding truth is the consideration of different perspectives. This is very important; our individual experiences shape us, make us more inclined to say one thing rather than another. We can be selective towards certain facts that can portray several truths.

Woolf challenges the traditional biography, the conventional listing of facts and dates in "Orlando", and explores the female identity in "A Room of One's Own", both achieved by combining fact and fiction. If it weren't for the latter, Orlando could not have aged 36 years in 400 and thereby present a truth: events that have passed before us are inextricable in terms of their effects on the present. In addition, Orlando could not have been accosted by the three angels, "purity", "modesty" and "chastity" to change from a man into a woman. As a result, any of the reader's preconceptions about gender would have become exposed- it is made clear that Orlando has not changed in any other way and neither should the way that he, or she is viewed.

In "A Room of One's Own", the imaginary character of Judith Shakespeare, paralleled to the real brother, illuminates a truth in how difficult it was to be a woman, one who could never have been able to overcome oppression, however talented, to achieve what a brother could. The cornerstone image of "A Room of One's Own" is imaginary, symbolic of women's potential and the freedom women could and should have had, in addition to intimating the restrictions placed by domesticity and societal expectations.

... Surely greater truths can be reached with such devices of the imagination? If Jane Austen or the Bronte sisters didn't have to hide their manuscript papers everytime someone walked into the communal sitting room where they worked, if they had a room of their own- perhaps they would have produced something quite different. It is the imaginary component that throws these truths into the foreground so completely. Virginia Woolf did so much for feminist literature and explored women's identity in a way that could not have been done by examining pure fact.

Monday, 11 October 2010

The Merry Wives of Windsor (The Globe theatre)

It always amazes me how Shakespeare knew so much about women! He defies the feminist who argues that one has to be a woman to offer anything insightful of the female roles in society. Anyone would adore this pair of merry wives for their wit in teaching poor Falstaff a lesson. Commissioned by Queen Lizzie herself, Shakespeare expertly puts the audience in the best of spirits. It was his only play set in Elizabethan times and the location of Windsor was inextricably intwined by association in courtly circles. Mistress Anne Page and her suitors are exemplary in our understanding of how people were viewed depending on their wealth or influence. Her mother favours a man of connections, although he is a pompous Frenchman, her father favours the idiot Master Slender, because he is rich and he is good friends with the boy's uncle. Even though Anne Page and Master Fenton's relationship is presented as the ideal one in contrast, due to their mutual love- Master Fenton confesses his initial attraction at least, was based on her wealth, particularly when he has squandered his own money on high-class living.

The play lends itself naturally to absolute hilarity, but this interpretation sparkles- and Falstaff is the gem. Actor Christopher Benjamin delivers his schemes and thoughts in such a way as to lead the audience to admiration for how well he takes abuse from the pair of crafty wives. So who is the fool? Both Slender and Caius run off to church with the wrong bride and Hodge completely overreacts to his wife's innocent schemes. Perhaps when observing one's contemporaries, it is easier to see fools. Time distances us, giving us the luxury of a detached perspective, but when exploring the current state of affairs, perhaps comedy is the best way to gain any understanding from it. I'm certainly looking forward to watching "Mock the Week" and "Have I Got News for You" tonight.